Kirby Wiki talk:Superstar Arena/Archive 1

→This is where, you submit your ideas for battles. when posting ideas do this

the team battle
User: N/A 7:52 PM 30 October 2008 (utc) " Have you guys ever thought of a Major Showdown?" Marx Soul should face off against Drawcia Soul! Soulful Clash! Lets see what will happen when souls attack each other. May the best soul win!

Thothgamer 05:11, 7 July 2008 (UTC)'''hmm... i have an idea that will satisfy everyone, okay?''' team club: commander-meta knight dark meta knight main transportation-dragoon wheelie crazy hand

♣

team spade: commander-dedede bugsy painter roller main transportation-hydra Master Hand Capsule J ♠ votes for the ultimate showdown sign here

I vote

i vote ParaGoomba348 00:06, 8 July 2008 (UTC)

I vote Thothgamer 05:11, 7 July 2008 (UTC)

i vote

ivote for thiss this counts as 10,000,000,000,009 votes right here

I vote Team Club(Favorite:Meta knight,D Meta Knight,Dragoon,Crazy Hand)DragoonRider 07:51, 31 July 2008

Let's Go Dark Meta Knight!

I TOTALLY VOTE 4 the DRAGOON.You should see what it does on SSBBDragoonRider12:41 24 July 2008

I vote Mr. Shine and Mr. Bright vs. Lololo and Lalala User: Novafan365

your idea
Metaknight vs bugsy

Accept
I accept

Coments
two warriors both with different fighting tactics. Will it be meta knights mach 5 speed or bugsy's boulder crushing power? votes for metaknight vs bugsy here:

I'm thothgamer and i just love a good sword fight, bugsy and metaknight!!!! -}=====- Thothgamer 00:16, 1 June 2008 (UTC) i vote I vote!!!! But where is the page on bugsy he(?) is like my favorite monster on the kirby anime and he deserves a page about him. (It's Bugzzy)

So do I as vote number 4 Solar flute 00:55, 21 June 2008 (UTC) I cant make up my mind(my favorite character is Meta Knight but Bugsy is really strong)If it possible I say its a TIE ^-^UDragoonRider12:47,24 July 2008

I vote King Doo

I vote-gumbal1

I'm not realy a user here, but just hear me out. Here is my idea: Meta Knight vs. O2 So, uh yeah. If you would, at the very least consider this then that would be great.

Huh, Meta Knight vs. O2... That's not a bad idea. After all, both of them are awsome beyond all reason... Lord Xale 18:32, 1 July 2008 (UTC) Not a bad idea,Yeah this could work.DragoonRider12:50,24 July 2008

-- Meta Knight v.s. O2==

--Meta Knight vs. Dark Meta Knight--

ParaGoomba348 04:20, 18 June 2008 (UTC)ParaGoomba348, 19:20, 18 June 2008

I think a blood relative fight would be good.

your idea
Master Hand vs. Crazy Hand

accept
I accept.

comments
A good Kirby and Smash Bros. Fight! 2 hands verses eachother...would be cool. User:SUPERSMASHKIRBY Master H & Crazy H My favorite is Crazy Hand Id say Crazy Hand!^^DragoonRider13:02,24 July 2008 -

Your idea
meta Knight vs. King dedede

Accept
I accept

comments
The two most common foes in the Kirby series, A swordmaster amd a Hammer wielder. Who will victorious? Solar flute 00:55, 21 June 2008 (UTC)

votes here:

What about another battle of Bugsy/Metaknight/Sword/Blade Knight vs. Bonkers/King dedede?DragoonRider 12:53,24 July 2008

I chose them because kirby faces them more then any other boss Solar flute

Capsule Brawl!
Capsule J vs. Capsule J2. Two of the same kind. Who will rocket to victory? VOTE NOW! User:Novafan365

Hm...I'll probably have to scratch all that. How about Paint Roller vs. Wheelie? They both roll a lot, and they both have wheels somewhere! ParaGoomba348 22:56, 1 July 2008 (UTC)

Votes here: Id say Paint Roller.He RULZ!(My favorite boss on Kirby: Canvas Curse^^)DragoonRider12:57,24 July 2008

I woud say wheelie would win.

2 Blade Kirby Battle!!!
(This is a minor battle)A battle of Sword Kirby vs Cutter Kirby. 2 heroes with a strong blade in hand!Who will win this 2 blade Battle?DragoonRider13:26,24 July 2008

I vote Sword Kirby. Once he gets in close and starts slashing at Cutter Kirby, there'll be nothing he can do.

Votes Here: crazy hand vs. master hand

My Ideas
Suggestions for 1 on 1 battles-

1a. Kirby vs. Meta Knight 2b. Kirby vs. Dedede 1c. Meta vs. Dedede 2. Poppy Bros. Sr. vs. Bonkers 3. Simmirror vs. Gim 4. Star Rod vs. the candy item that makes Kirby invincible 5. Kirby vs. Dark Kirby 6. Meta vs. Dark Meta

1a.TIE(Both fav) 2b.Kirby 1c.Meta Knight 2.Poppy Bros. Sr 3.???? 4.TIE(Luv em both^^) 5.Kirby^^ 6.TIE(I lik em both^v^)DragoonRider14:03 08 August 2008

Question
When are we going to have Waddle Dee vs. Waddle Doo over? Its become vicious and hasn't even ended.--KirbyFan 22:29, 8 August 2008 (UTC)

I dislike the Waddle Dee & Waddle Doo!!I taking off my vote!!>.<xDragoonRider 12:48, 8 August 2008

Keeby vs. Shadow Kirby
two pallete swaps of the pink hero. Solar flute vote here:

Mr. Shine & Mr. Bright VS. Lololo & Lalala
Two pairs. Both enemies. Vote now below. --Blue Ninjakoopa 05:04, 17 August 2008 (UTC)

Maybe it should be a tag team battle. Just saying.-gumbal1 (Kirby equivalent of Chuck Norris is this)

Dark Meta Knight vs. Dark Mind
Two mirror versions of other characters. More evil than Dedede. I didn't know that was possible.

Votes here:

Dark mind is going to win by a longshot, probably. Solar flute I Think Heart Of NOVA shold fight Galactic Nova Nucleus.

not a new fight, but...
at zeldapedia's temple of courage, (zeldapedian equivalent of orange ocean) we keep the last fight up, we just add a new fight up when  a new fight is added. visit to understand what i am saying. I am saying that we should do the same.

Hmmm... how about no. --Blue Ninjakoopa 16:55, 4 September 2008 (UTC)

why not? Solar flute

Does the word "opinion" ring a bell. This is Kirby Wiki, not Zeldapedia. --Blue Ninjakoopa 10:35, 5 September 2008 (UTC)

New Fight
We're gonna go with half of Solar Flute's Idea (using Dark mind) for the fight (not the Zeldapedia thing, just the two she mentioned). Then mine. --Blue Ninjakoopa 23:43, 5 September 2008 (UTC)

The Final Countdown!
Team Kirby: Kirby Meta Knight Nightmare King Dedede Paint Roller Master Hand Knuckle Joe Heavy Lobster Mr. Shine and Mr. Bright

Team Shadow Kirby: Shadow Kirby Dark Meta Knight Dark Mind Escargoon Wheelie Crazy Hand Keeby Heavy Mole Lololo and Lalala

Votes for the final countdown sign here!

This might be a pretty cool fight! King Doo

I agree-gumbal1

How about...
I just had an idea. Because this is basically a place for character battles, why don't we rename the page "The Arena"? It would make things easier to understand for newer users, and basically makes more sense than having a constantly changing name. We can still have the changing setting (like how this time is Candy Constellation), but we would have the page (overall) called The Arena. -EmptyStar
 * Hmmm, I like it! It would definitely be much easier for naming purposes and for new users such as myself. -
 * As you wish...--[[Image:Kirbysqsq.png|25px]] KirbyFan (talk|contributions|logs) 13:29, 27 September 2008 (UTC)

NOOOOOOOO! The Superstar arena is fine. LEAVE IT!  Blue Ninjakoopa Talk to me 14:27, 27 September 2008 (UTC)
 * Haha, I stated this a while ago. Thanks for helping Kirbyfan, it's just that what I wanted was fulfilled with the renaming of it as Superstar Arena. Sorry for the big misunderstanding. -EmptyStar
 * Sigh. Whatever.  Blue Ninjakoopa Talk to me 14:34, 27 September 2008 (UTC)

Solution to the name debate
We should stop renaming it.-- KirbyFan (talk|contributions|logs) 15:44, 27 September 2008 (UTC)

It's about time you wrote something smart.  Blue Ninjakoopa Talk to me 16:44, 27 September 2008 (UTC)

???-- KirbyFan (talk|contributions|logs) 01:30, 28 September 2008 (UTC)

But the arena is a better name and makes more sense King Doo

Still, Superstar Arena may be called that because of the Arena in Kirby Super Star.-gumbal1 (Kirby equivalent of Chuck Norris is this)

We need...
...A "Kirby Wiki: Superstar Arena Acrchive".-- KirbyFan (talk|contributions|logs) 14:01, 28 September 2008 (UTC)
 * Not yet, mah boi.  Blue Ninjakoopa Talk to me 19:57, 3 October 2008 (UTC)

My idea...
Ado vs. Adeleine. 'nuff said. -EmptyStar

I originally planned on it being Meta Knight vs. Dark Meta Knight.  Blue Ninjakoopa Talk to me 19:59, 3 October 2008 (UTC)

I won't do it again.
KirbyFan/R.O.B 128, I will never rig the Superstar Arena again! I PROMISE!

Exploding Snowman vs. Ice Bomb
Two abilities that are made by mixing ice and bomb. Solar flute

I like your idea, Solar Flute, but what we need are images of those two. Let's stick with things that actually live for now.  Blue Ninjakoopa Talk to me 15:23, 28 October 2008 (UTC)

cleanup
We should have a section for each fight on this talk page. Solar flute

for example things would be like this:

Pengy vs. Mr. Flosty
-brief explanation of the relation, in this case ice creatures

Votes

 * 1) Voter's comments and

That is a bad idea because Mr. Flosty is a mini boss while Pengy is a regular enemy.

or it could be like this:

Master vs. Triple Star
Two awesome final abilities.

support

 * 1) Voter's comments and

oppose

 * 1) voter's opposition and

comments
Any comments go here

What do you think (about the way to organize this place, not the fight itself)? Solar flute 04:59, 31 October 2008 (UTC)

Are you asking me? If so, I think it's a great idea.  Blue Ninjakoopa Talk to me 15:25, 31 October 2008 (UTC)

My thought
Zero Two versus anything, but preferrebly Dark Mind

Dark Meta & Meta vs Galacta
It would be awsome if Dark Meta Knight and Meta Knight teamed up to defeat Galacta Knight! I'm looking forward to it! Yeah!

2 Poppy bros. vs. a Senior
Kevinhead 22:04, 21 November 2008 (UTC) 2 POPPY BROS. JRS VS. A POPPY BROS. SENIOR It would be awesome!!!!!!

Gooey Vs. Keeby

Two characters battle for friendship with Kirby. Who will reign victorious?

King Dedede Vs. heavy lobster
A king and a metal robot who will win?

Dark and Normal VS Dark and Normal!
My idea was that there should be a battle between Meta Knight & Dark Meta Knight VS Daroach & Dark Daroach!

Marx Showdown!!
Marx VS Marx Soul!

*Slaps face*
Don't you know who will win ALREADY?!?!?! Sorry for that. It's just that the winner is already known.-gumbal1

THIS IS STUPID! STUPID STUPID STUPID!

The winner is obvious but this would still be really cool. KD(King DOO)

= Hmm.... =

I would probably go for this:

Dedede VS. Zero

Why? Both had a rematch VS. Kirby in different forms. (Dedede had Masked Dedede, and Zero had 02.)

Timson622222 02:35, 23 December 2008 (UTC)Timson622222

=Heavy battle=

Heavy Lobster vs. Heavy Mole

Both giant mechs!
 * I love this idea! This will be our next fight! This is BNK btw using my school's IP address. 64.72.67.162 17:01, 6 January 2009 (UTC)

=The Galactic Fate of the Universe: NOVA vs. Nightmare=

Having Kirby's Adventure and Kirby Super Star Ultra, I thought it would be nice to have these giant beings face each other. Wishes and Darkness. A destined battle.

Marx Soul vs. Dark Mind: A Clash of Blackness
Two dark beings. Which is the more evil?
 * Hmmm... 64.72.67.162 17:01, 6 January 2009 (UTC)

Arm Wrestling
Wham Bam Jewel & Wham Bam Rock VS. Master Hand and Crazy Hand. 'Nuff said.

I think Master Hand And Crazy Hand would win.

I like this idea. This is BNK btw using my school's IP address. 64.72.67.162 16:59, 6 January 2009 (UTC)

(in response to 64.72.67.162|64.72.67.162)

Thanks.

- Creator of this Topic

PLZ post your next comment(s) under a line made of -s (like the one below this message)

4 on 4 Showdown!
Kirby, Meta Knight, Knuckle Joe, and Sirica vs. O2, Marx, Galacta Knight, and Nightmare. Epic chaos ensues.
 * That's a bit too much. 64.72.67.162 16:59, 6 January 2009 (UTC)

Free for all! All for One, and One for All
Every Kirby character v.s each other from all the games and the anime! The Ultimate Showdown!
 * O.o 64.72.67.162 16:59, 6 January 2009 (UTC)

Mirical Matter vs. Zero two
Btw, we should archive the fights...
 * We would need a solid picture of Miracle Matter. lol http://i194.photobucket.com/albums/z25/Jumpie7/Mario/ani_smwkoopatroopared.gif  Blue  Ninjakoopa  http://i194.photobucket.com/albums/z25/Jumpie7/Mario/ani_smwkoopatroopared.gif 17:57, 28 January 2009 (UTC)


 * True, lol

Go Miracle Matter! King Doo(KD)


 * No go Zero Two. IM NOT EMO! STOP LOOKING AT ME!!!

I vote for Zero Two!-gumbal1 (Kirby equivalent of Chuck Norris is this)

Zero Two Vs. Marx Soul:The Clash of the Fallen
The Angel of the Black Star Vs. The Insane Traitor! UPDATE! Sorry for not putting my name-gumbal1 (Kirby equivalent of Chuck Norris is this) Two reincarnated being seeking to destroy! votes             comments King Doo      Two awesome foes collide!

Giant Bobo VS. Boboo
Two big bobos. Who will win? Mr Boring's Idea

Sounds pleasing! I vote!

Wiz vs. 5 Boxys
Wiz won once, but is his magic strong enough for 5 boxys magic? Mr Boring's Idea

Wiz deserves a stronger match! I vote This one!

I vote! Go Wiz! King Doo

I love this Idea! I vote!

What makes me like this is the moving to the next round idea. So I vote.

Better than my idea! You got my vote!-gumbal1

chilly vs. frigis
chilly moves onto the next level of ice enemy battles! will he win again? Mr Boring's Idea

hmm... not bad! I like this idea! I vote!

gumbal1 has your vote!-gumbal1

you got my vote. King Doo

This needs to become more orderly.
Yeah. I think we should archive this and create a new talk page. To promote this in a more orderly manner I think we should add these rules and guidelines for suggesting battles: Well, that's all I have to say. EmptyStar 18:43, 1 February 2009 (UTC)
 * The two combatants should be related in some way.
 * definitely the most important one. A battle should have some meaning to it. So rather than suggesting things that aren't at all related like "Chilly vs. Marx Soul", try something like "Blipper vs. Squishy. The theme there being aquatic enemies. Essentially, having a basis to the battle really does make it easier to vote on.
 * Try not to nominate combatants who were already in contests. Especially ones that already won.
 * Not too much of a big one, but it's not good to establish "arena regulars". The contests should be jarring, and have something new every time. Sure, we all know Marx is the most epic character ever, but if we stick him in every time, it would get boring!
 * Steer clear of final bosses.
 * Most of the suggestions listed on the talk page is made up of final bosses. While they might make for an entertaining fight once in a while, most of them are very similar to each other and don't leave room for diversity in the battles. Contrary to common belief, having a fight against a final bosses every time would get REALLY boring after a while.
 * Don't nominate 'nobodies'.
 * Although "Pedo vs. Rockn" may fit all the above rules.... absolutely no one knows who they are! Just because you know who they are don't come to the conclusion that everyone else does! Many of our voters aren't members OR Kirby experts, so if you nominate things that nobody heard of, don't expect a big turn out.
 * No team battles.... or at lest not yet.
 * No. The ultimate battle isn't made up of 12 really popular/epic characters. Besides, how could we fit pictures of 6 characters on each side!? Oh, that's another thing, try to nominate things that we have official art for, because using sprites in the battle doesn't look right.

Can we include teams like Lololo and Lalala? What if the team only has two people like Meta Knight and King DeDeDe? Please answer. King Doo
 * Lololo and Lalala are practically counted as the same character and are never seen apart, so they're alright. But ones that consist of two completely different characters, like Dedede and Meta Knight aren't. Besides, would it really make a difference if i was just Meta Knight? Because of his popularity, he alone is able to wipe the floor with almost anyone, haha. Also, what battle were you thinking of with Dedede and Meta Knight? EmptyStar 00:24, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

I was just wondering. Shouldn't there be a rule like nobody can fight themselves like Marx and Marx Soul or Fire Kirby and Beam Kirby? King Doo
 * Nah. I think that would be nitpicking. As long people would vote for either character. EmptyStar 02:21, 2 February 2009 (UTC)


 * Also we should remove rule #5 because it is a popularity contest...

My battles
Meta Knight vs. Dorach. Meta Knight's speed and sword skills vs. Dorach's ultimate magic. Who will win? King Doo